Deterring Talent Migration

Why staying at home makes sense

Many relatives and friends in my inner circle frequently advise me that, despite possessing significant qualifications and experience, I haven’t achieved much in Pakistan. Given the increasing number of people leaving the country, they suggest that I should also consider relocating and exploring better opportunities abroad. Some close associates even forward various advertisements and links related to employment and immigration opportunities in foreign countries. Having lived in and visited several nations in the past, I am well aware that while there are advantages, there are also numerous drawbacks to living away from one’s home country. This topic warrants a detailed exploration.

For me, the paramount consideration is patriotism. The histories of prosperous nations reveal that a key factor behind their success lies in the citizens’ deep-seated patriotism and love for their homeland. Patriotism, characterized by fervent love and devotion to one’s country, has consistently proven to be a timeless and influential force shaping historical trajectories. Beyond mere displays of flags and anthems, patriotism functions as a unifying and motivating factor crucial to a nation’s stability, growth, and overall well-being. It acts as the adhesive binding diverse groups into a cohesive national identity, fostering a sense of belonging and shared purpose that transcends differences in race, religion, or ethnicity.

A patriotic spirit often ignites a collective aspiration for progress and development. When individuals feel a profound connection to their country, they are more inclined to actively contribute to its advancement. This contribution may manifest in efforts to enhance education, infrastructure, and technological advancements. Patriotism serves as the impetus for citizens to defend the core values that define their nation, be it democracy, freedom, or justice. A robust sense of patriotism acts as a bulwark against internal and external threats to these values, motivating citizens to stand against injustice and work toward positive societal change.

Whether facing economic downturns, natural disasters, or other challenges, a strong national spirit fosters unity and a willingness to make sacrifices for the greater good. This collective resilience contributes significantly to a nation’s ability to overcome adversity. Moreover, patriotism promotes the celebration of diversity within a nation, emphasizing that people from different backgrounds can unite under a common flag. This inclusivity enhances social cohesion, fostering a harmonious and vibrant society.

Patriotism also extends to the preservation of a nation’s history, culture, and traditions. Citizens who take pride in their heritage are more likely to support efforts aimed at protecting and promoting their unique identity. This, in turn, enriches and diversifies the global cultural landscape. Additionally, a nation with a patriotic citizenry tends to enjoy a more favorable position in the international arena. Strong diplomatic ties and international cooperation are facilitated when a country’s people are dedicated to its success, enhancing its global standing and contributing to diplomatic initiatives that benefit its citizens.

The notion of a homeland holds profound significance in the identity and sense of belonging for individuals globally. Nevertheless, some individuals, for various reasons, find themselves without a country to claim as their own. The absence of a homeland often results in a significant loss of identity and a feeling of not belonging. Nationality closely intertwines with personal identity, and the lack of a country can leave individuals adrift.

The absence of a homeland can lead to various legal and political obstacles. Lack of citizenship restricts access to fundamental rights and services, including healthcare, education, and employment opportunities. Stateless individuals may find themselves in a legal limbo, encountering difficulties in obtaining documentation and facing potential deportation.

The lack of citizenship severely limits an individual’s freedom to travel. Stateless individuals may encounter challenges in obtaining visas and may face additional scrutiny at borders. This restriction on mobility can impact opportunities for personal and professional growth, hindering the pursuit of education or employment opportunities abroad. Being without a homeland often carries social stigma and misconceptions, leading to discrimination and exclusion on both personal and societal levels. This can contribute to mental health challenges, intensifying feelings of alienation and despair. Additionally, the absence of legal protection and rights can render individuals without a homeland vulnerable to exploitation.

Living and working overseas can be a rewarding experience. However, it brings its own set of challenges. Adapting to a new culture can be one of the most significant hurdles, with language barriers, unfamiliar customs, and social norms creating a sense of isolation and disorientation. Even if one is a citizen of a foreign country, they may still experience a secondary status.

Navigating the legal and administrative systems of a foreign country can be daunting, with challenges in obtaining visas, work permits, and other essential documentation. Career-related obstacles are common, as qualifications obtained in one’s homeland may not always be recognized, and employment opportunities can be competitive. Access to healthcare becomes a significant concern, with differences in healthcare systems and potential language barriers complicating matters. Securing adequate health insurance coverage may not always be straightforward.

Managing finances in a foreign country involves dealing with currency exchange rates, fluctuating living costs, and tax implications, leading to unexpected financial challenges for expatriates. Being physically distant from family and the familiar comforts of home culture can be emotionally taxing, making it challenging to celebrate holidays, important milestones, and maintain relationships. Families with children may encounter educational challenges due to differences in education systems, curricula, and language barriers, impacting a child’s academic progress and requiring extensive research to find suitable schools aligning with educational expectations.

In an increasingly interconnected world, individuals frequently find themselves contemplating the possibility of departing their home country during periods of economic uncertainty. The attraction of stability, job opportunities, and improved living conditions abroad can be enticing. However, there are compelling reasons to consider remaining in one’s home country amidst an economic crisis. One of the primary advantages of staying in one’s home country during an economic downturn is the support network that local communities can offer. Friends, family, and neighbours often unite during challenging times, providing emotional support and practical assistance. Being part of a community familiar with local dynamics provides a sense of belonging and solidarity that might be challenging to replicate elsewhere. Those intimately acquainted with the local culture, job market, and economic landscape are better equipped to navigate challenges during a crisis.

Economic crises are cyclical, and historical patterns show that recovery often follows downturns. By remaining in the home country, individuals position themselves to benefit from the eventual economic upswing. Those engaged in local business, education, or real estate may find themselves well-placed to capitalize on opportunities as the economy rebounds. Transferring assets across borders can be a complex and costly process. During economic crises, currency values may fluctuate, making it challenging to safeguard one’s financial portfolio. Keeping assets within the country allows individuals to mitigate risks associated with currency volatility and maintain a more stable financial foundation. Staying in a country during an economic crisis provides an opportunity to actively contribute to its recovery. By participating in local initiatives, supporting small businesses, and engaging in community development, individuals can play a role in rebuilding the economic fabric of their homeland. Economic downturns present excellent opportunities for self-improvement and skill development. Remaining in the home country enables individuals to pursue further education, gain additional qualifications, and enhance their professional skills, positioning themselves for success when economic conditions improve.

During economic crises, practising financial responsibility becomes paramount. Individuals can contribute to overall stability by managing their finances wisely, avoiding unnecessary debt, and saving for the future. Responsible financial behaviour on an individual level enhances the nation’s economic resilience. Active citizen engagement involves advocating for policies promoting economic recovery and addressing systemic issues. Individuals can participate in community forums, engage with policymakers, and support initiatives aiming to create a more robust and equitable economic system. A focus on sustainability and environmental conservation contributes to long-term economic recovery. Initiatives promoting green technologies, energy efficiency, and environmental responsibility benefit not only the planet but also stimulate growth in emerging industries.

Civic engagement is a powerful tool for change. Individuals can actively participate in the democratic process by staying informed about economic policies, voting in elections, and holding elected officials accountable. A politically engaged citizenry contributes to the formulation of policies aligning with the nation’s economic interests.

The details outlined above provide a nuanced understanding of the advantages and disadvantages of living and working overseas. Despite the financial challenges faced by Pakistan, the situation is gradually improving. The nation is advancing towards political steadiness with high hopes pinned on the incoming government. Collaboration between the military and civilian authorities is exceptional, with the military committed to offering comprehensive support to address both internal and external challenges alongside the government. With the concerted efforts of figures like COAS Gen Asim Munir, who is actively addressing issues and fostering positive change, the country is witnessing positive signs. Efforts to reduce the prices of the dollar, petrol, and goods, along with substantial foreign investments, indicate a positive trajectory. The solution lies not in leaving the country but in staying, finding opportunities within the current situation, and contributing positively. Choosing to remain in Pakistan presents an opportunity to play a role in spreading positivity, productivity, and patriotism, contributing to the collective spirit needed for the nation’s progress.

Abdul Basit Alvi
Abdul Basit Alvi
The writer is a freelance columnist


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Must Read

Former US ambassador who spied for Cuba sentenced to 15 years

MIAMI: A former US ambassador who pleaded guilty to spying for Cuba for over four decades was sentenced in federal court on Friday to...