A Strange Case in Central Asia

The China-Russia equation

China and Russia are converging in Central Asia where their own interests are concerned. Both the countries has the desire for a terrorism-free region and for its stability, particularly in Afghanistan. They also desired that the USA exit from the region and at last the USA left Afghanistan. After the US departure from Afghanistan, China and Russia are ramping up their security assistance to the regional states. However, this situation does not point to their competition. After the US departure from Afghanistan, the new Taliban government is participating in the military exercise which has been organized by Russia, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan just 20km away from the Afghan border. A few days after China will hold counter terrorism drills with Tajikistan for the public security. China has been providing assistance to Tajikistan near the Afghan border since 2016.

The withdrawal of US troops from the region shows Washington’s limited interest in the Central Asian states. Post 9/11, when the  USA started operations in Afghanistan, it used Central Asia as a logistics hub and opened bases in Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan. By 2014, these bases were closed and a series of supply lines to Afghanistan through the Northern Distribution Network, Russia and Central Asia, which began in 2009, were shut down in 2015 after growing tensions between Washington and Moscow. Although the US government has promised to build new facilities on the Tajik border with Afghanistan, this security assistance has fallen from a high of $450 million to just $11 million in 2020.

Although China and Russia have many differences and these differences may remain in the near future, there are indications that both the countries are thinking about their strategic position in the world. Both the countries have established their own goals and have also taken several measures without each other

- Advertisement -

Russia is a key security provider in the region. It has maintained military installations in Kazakhstan, Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan. Half of the import of arms for Central Asia is managed from Russia. Russia also has conducted 121 joint exercises with the regional states since their independence. Russia has a number of mechanisms for providing security, both bilateral and multilateral, such as the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) and the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CESTO). Although the Russian share in the regional arms market has been stable over the past decade, it has nonetheless increased its share in regional exercises from 39 percent to 49 percent.

Russian arms have  a relatively low price and make it easy to make deals with poor Central Asian states like Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan. Russia has often donated only weapons and most recently 12 BRDM-2M patrol vehicles were delivered to Tajikistan in mid-September 2021.  It is probably also helpful that the most senior officers in the evaluation and ordering processes started their careers as Soviet officers, and were trained on what is now Russian equipment.

Russian exercises are on average twice as large as those of its nearest rival, China. Unlike China, which has focused on developing ties with the Central Asian security services and police forces, Russia has focused on military cooperation with the regional States. Two-thirds of the Russian-led joint exercises were carried out by the Russian military or air force. In recent years, Russia has also demonstrated its potential as a military power in the region.

In August 2018, Russian forces in Tajikistan launched a series of airstrikes against drug traffickers. It was their first armed intervention in Afghan politics since the 1989 Soviet withdrawal. Since the rise of the Taliban, Russia has been testing its logistics networks to deliver Mi-8 and Mi-24 helicopters to Gasar Air Base outside Dushanbe in case of instability in Afghanistan. Rapid response capabilities have been enhanced to strengthen the Tajik border, and Russia has also moved Su-25 strike aircraft from Kyrgyzstan to Gasar.

On the other hand, China’s economic and strategic role in the region also is growing day by day. In the Arms market its share has increased from 1.5 percent to 13 percent over the past decade. China is also making strategic strides in the areas where Russia lags behind in terms of technology, such as with drones. China has sold its CH-3, CH-4, CH-5 and Wing Long drones to regional states such as Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. China has also been more active in strategic exercises and has conducted 35 joint military exercises, either bilaterally or through the SCO.

China started playing a more significant and active role in the Central Asian strategic arena in 2014. It wanted to prevent Xinjiang from the spreading instability of Afghanistan. These national goals have forced Beijing to focus primarily on integrating its internal security services, paramilitary forces, and counterterrorism forces with neighboring states.

- Advertisement -

The security natures of the exercises also show that China wants to continue to cool Russia, which understands itself as a key security player in the region. Beijing has shown respect for Moscow here in the past. In 2017, the Development Research Centre, an influential think tank under the Chinese cabinet, invited high-profile Russian researchers to a private seminar to determine Moscow’s red lines in the region. In 2021, the Sibu/Interaction exercise was conducted, which was the largest ever held between Chinese and Russian forces.  It demonstrates that both the countries have focused more on joint operations, including command and control, than in previous exercises and also suggest deeper cooperation.

Although China and Russia have many differences and these differences may remain in the near future, there are indications that both the countries are thinking about their strategic position in the world. Both the countries have established their own goals and have also taken several measures without each other.

Russia has made a deal of exporting arms to India while China has also organized military exercises outside the SCO and has set up its own mechanism. Additionally, it arranged the China + Central Asia Foreign Ministers Meeting, which began on May 12, and worked on counter-terrorism with Pakistan.

Though communism has collapsed in Russia, its relations with China are beginning to resemble those it had before the Chinese rapprochement with the USA. However, while Russia is not the supower the USSR was, China is not yet the superpower it seems set fair to becoming.

Dr Muhammad Akram Zaheer
The writer has a PhD in Political Science and can be reached at [email protected]


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Must Read

Muslim woman sentenced to death for sending blasphemous content on WhatsApp

RAWALPINDI: A Muslim woman was sentenced to death by a Rawalpindi court on Wednesday after being convicted of sending blasphemous content via WhatsApp. The 26-year-old...

Preparing for Change

Forced marriages